South Dakota v. Wayfair

July 18, 2018
Category:

South Dakota v. Wayfair is old news as a Supreme Court case, decided back in 2018. But the sales tax rules it created are still changing, and most of what small business owners think they know about them is a few years out of date. Here’s where things actually stand in 2026.

01

What the Case Actually Decided

Before 2018, a state could only require you to collect its sales tax if your business had a physical presence there, a store, a warehouse, an employee. That standard came from a 1992 case, Quill Corp. v. North Dakota. South Dakota v. Wayfair overturned it. States can now require an out-of-state seller to collect sales tax based purely on economic activity in that state, no physical presence required. That concept is called economic nexus, and it’s the reason an online seller with no employees or property outside their home state can still owe sales tax collection duties in dozens of others.

02

What Economic Nexus Looks Like in 2026

Most states settled on a threshold of $100,000 in annual sales to trigger the requirement. What’s changed more recently is the second half of the old rule: many states originally paired that dollar threshold with a 200-transaction count, so a seller could trip the requirement on volume alone, even with modest revenue. States have been dropping that transaction count.

South Dakota itself removed its own 200-transaction threshold in 2023, leaving just the $100,000 sales figure. Since then, more than a dozen other states have done the same, including California, Colorado, Illinois, North Carolina, Washington, and Wisconsin.

Not every state fits the standard pattern. A few notable exceptions:

State2026 Threshold
California, Texas$500,000 in sales
New York$500,000 in sales AND 100+ transactions
Alabama, Mississippi$250,000 in sales
Most other states$100,000 in sales, no transaction count
Nexus isn’t something you decide. It’s something your sales numbers decide for you, state by state, without asking first.
03

What This Means If You Sell Online

  • Crossing a state’s threshold means you’re responsible for registering, collecting, and remitting that state’s sales tax, even with zero physical presence there
  • If you sell through a marketplace like Amazon, Etsy, or Walmart, marketplace facilitator laws generally shift the collection duty to the platform itself, but this doesn’t always cover your own website or direct sales
  • Thresholds are calculated per state, so a seller shipping nationwide can end up tracking nexus in far more states than they’d expect
  • Rules vary enough between states that what applied to your business in California may not apply the same way in Texas or New York
04

What To Do About It

The starting point is knowing where your revenue is actually coming from. You can’t tell whether you’ve crossed a state’s threshold if your books don’t break sales down by state, and that’s a bookkeeping question before it’s a tax question. From there, it’s worth reviewing which of your sales channels already have marketplace facilitator coverage and which don’t, so you’re not assuming protection you don’t actually have.

Know Where Your Revenue Is Actually Coming From

Our $97 QBO Health Check reviews your full file, including how your sales are categorized, so you have the numbers you need before a nexus question becomes a compliance problem. The fee is credited toward any service you start with us.

Book Your QBO Health Check $97 flat fee, credited toward future services

Related Posts

  • Holiday Bonuses and Employee Gifts: What Business Owners Need to Know About Payroll Taxes.

    Holiday Bonuses and Employee Gifts: What Business Owners Need to Know About Payroll Taxes

    Handing out a holiday bonus or a gift is one of the nicest things a business owner does all year.…

    View More
  • Business owner S-corp year-end checklist

    The S-Corp Owner’s Year-End Checklist: What to Do Before December 31

    Year-end checklists tend to be written for everyone, which is why they skip the parts that are unique to S-corp…

    View More
  • 1099 reporting threshold changes for 2026

    The 1099 Threshold Is Now $2,000: What Changed and What Didn’t

    For years, the magic number for 1099s was $600. Pay a contractor that much in a year and you owed…

    View More
  • Business owner reviewing payroll numbers to determine a reasonable S-corp salary

    How the IRS Actually Decides What’s a “Reasonable” S-Corp Salary

    If you’ve made the S-corp election, you already know the appeal: pay yourself a salary, take the rest as a…

    View More